All posts

On Betrayal (by Companies)

I tweeted earlier about my frustration with the new “SiriAI” (the one released a couple months ago and based on Gemini) and how much worse it is than the original Siri (which has plenty of it’s own problems still).

It sends every single request to the remote server, handling nothing on device, so every request (even simple things like setting a timer) take much longer and yet, somehow, still tend to fail. While it is definitely better than old Siri at answering research questions (instead of just pulling up a web page for you), the main thing I use Siri for is setting timers, adding reminders, controlling things in the house, where speed and reliability are the most important. So Old Siri made it’s return.

Betrayal

But this isn’t about Siri per se, this is about the feeling of betrayal when companies and ecosystems that we’ve invested into fall short.

On one hand, it seems absurd to say that I feel betrayed by a company shipping a bad product, but no, I do! And this isn’t just because I’m an Apple fanboy (which I am to a degree). It’s because I made a deal with them, investing my money, my time, and my trust into their products over the years in return for the commitment that they would deliver quality products that just work and do the things they say they’ll do.

But I use the term ‘betrayal’ here because it feels worse when we get into what is now a years long saga of a company failing to deliver on a core promise of their product. Obviously everyone is going to have shortcomings at times, bugs slip out, phones crash, there are manufacturing defects. And customer service and warranties and apologies can remedy the short term and transient issues when they arise.

And of course the real problem is that we live in a duopoly where you only have one other choice and the rest of the Apple product still works pretty well so you just accept this unequal and abusive relationship where Apple keeps lying to you because changing operating systems across your entire digital life would be a lot worse. It’s that balance of power problem that makes it feel so bad. And I know that you’re going to prioritize your business over me, using the power that you have to charge higher prices, but at least you benefit from that! This is just pure incompetence that doesn’t help either of us!

I’m using Apple as the example here but it’s not just them. Think about the relationship that most regular travelers have with their airline of choice (though those also involve even more sophisticated uses of marketing and loyalty programs to manipulate you into embracing that particular abusive relationship).

Ultimately I’m not going to abandon Apple over it, just like I’m not going to stop flying United Airlines when they’re the one with consistently the best schedule for someone living in the mountain west.

But it does remind me why I’m an ardent believer in competition and multiple players - being stuck in a world with few choices is bleak.

Comments

No comments yet

Leave a comment